2008 Television Episodes

“Partners in Crime” is the first episode of the fourth series of British science fiction television series Doctor Who. It was broadcast on BBC One on 5 April 2008. The episode reintroduced comedienne Catherine Tate as Donna Noble, who previously appeared in “The Runaway Bride”. Donna and the Doctor (David Tennant) meet while separately investigating Adipose Industries, a company that has created a revolutionary diet pill. Together, they attempt to stop the death of thousands of people in London after the head of the company, the alien Miss Foster (Sarah Lancashire), creates the Adipose, short white aliens made from human body fat.

The episode’s alien creatures, the Adipose, were created using the software Massive, commonly used for crowd sequences in fantasy and science fiction films. The episode is stylistically different from other Doctor Who episodes; “Partners in Crime” has no clear antagonist, and the creatures are in a different style to Doctor Who‘s regular “big [and] scary” monsters.

“Partners in Crime” features the return of three other characters. Jacqueline King reprises her role as Sylvia Noble from “The Runaway Bride”. Bernard Cribbins reprises his role as Wilfred Mott from “Voyage of the Damned”. Cribbins was recalled to replace the character of Geoff Noble after actor Howard Attfield died. Billie Piper briefly reprises her role as Rose Tyler for the first time since the second series’ finale “Doomsday”, in a scene that was not included in preview showings.

The episode received many positive reviews. Most critics liked the special effects used to create the Adipose. Critics also praised Tate’s subdued acting in comparison to “The Runaway Bride”; Donna was changed from a “shouting fishwife” to a more emotional person when she became a full-time companion. Critics’ opinions were split over the episode’s plot: opinion on executive producer Russell T Davies’ writing ranged from “pure pleasure” to “the back of a fag packet”.

Synopsis

The episode primarily focuses on Donna Noble (Catherine Tate), a previous companion who appeared in “The Runaway Bride”. After her encounter with the Doctor (David Tennant), she became disenchanted with normal life and regretted declining his invitation to travel in the TARDIS. She started investigating conspiracy theories in the hope she would find him. She confides her regrets to her grandfather Wilfred Mott (Bernard Cribbins), an amateur astronomer who met the Doctor before in “Voyage of the Damned”.

The episode concerns Adipose Industries, which is marketing a diet pill to London’s population with the slogan “the fat just walks away”. Believing the treatment to be otherworldly, the Doctor and Donna investigate the company separately, and find that the slogan is literal—the pills use latent body fat to parthenogenetically create the Adipose, small white aliens which spawn every night, removing a little of the host’s body fat each time. In an emergency, multiple Adipose can spawn by using all of the body’s organic tissue, killing the host. When the Doctor and Donna meet, they are confronted by Miss Foster (Sarah Lancashire), an alien who is exploiting Britain’s overweight population to create the Adipose for the Adiposian First Family. Miss Foster mentions that the Adipose species “lost” their breeding planet and hired Foster to find a replacement; she chose Earth, knowing that it was illegal.

Foster accelerates her plans, feeling threatened by the Doctor’s invocation of galactic law and fearing he may inform the “Shadow Proclamation”, an interplanetary police force. Throughout London, the Adipose begin to spawn, soon numbering several thousand. The Doctor and Donna prevent total emergency parthenogenesis occurring, while the remainder make their way to Adipose Industries. The Adiposian First Family use their spaceship to collect the Adipose, but kill Foster to hide any evidence they used Earth illegally. The Doctor refrains from killing the Adipose because they are children; Donna notes that his previous companion Martha Jones made him more human, citing his infanticide of the Racnoss in their previous encounter.

At the end of the episode, Donna accepts an offer to travel in the TARDIS. She makes a detour to leave her car keys in a safe location for her mother Sylvia (Jacqueline King), and asks a blonde woman to help Sylvia find the keys. The woman turns towards the camera, revealing her to be Rose Tyler (Billie Piper). She fades from view as she walks away from the area. In the final scene, Donna asks the Doctor to fly by her grandfather, Wilfred, who sees her and celebrates on his allotment.

Production

Casting

“Partners in Crime” features several actors returning to the series. Catherine Tate was offered the opportunity to return as Donna Noble during lunch with executive producer Julie Gardner. Tate, who expected Gardner would ask about appearing in a biopic, later admitted it was “the furthest thing from [her] mind”. Tate’s return was controversial amongst Doctor Who fans; the criticism she received was compared to Daniel Craig after he was cast as James Bond. Howard Attfield, who appeared as Donna’s father Geoff in “The Runaway Bride”, filmed several scenes for this episode, but died before his scenes for the remainder of the season were completed. The producers retired his character out of respect, and dedicated him in the closing credits for the episode. Producer Phil Collinson suggested transferring his traits to the unrelated character Stan Mott from “Voyage of the Damned”, and rewriting his role as Donna’s grandfather. Executive producers Russell T Davies and Gardner liked the idea and recalled Bernard Cribbins to the role to re-film Attfield’s scenes, with the character renamed as Wilfred—a name Davies favoured for Donna’s grandfather—in time for the credits of “Voyage of the Damned” to be changed.

Writing

Davies took a different approach while writing the episode. David Tennant and Sarah Lancashire noted the character of Miss Foster had good intentions but was morally ambiguous. The premise of the Adipose pill was equally ambiguous with rare side-effects, but was a “win-win situation” for anyone involved. Davies based the character of Miss Foster on the “Supernanny” Jo Frost and Argentine philanthropist and politician Eva Perón, and Lancashire compared her character to Mary Poppins. The Adipose are a different style to regular Doctor Who villains; antagonists such as Lazarus in “The Lazarus Experiment” or the werewolf in “Tooth and Claw” were singular monsters designed to scare the audience; the Adipose were written as “cute” to provide a “bizarre [and] surreal” experience.

Davies made some changes to Donna’s character. The character was “rounded … out from being a shouting fishwife to someone who’s quite vulnerable and emotional”. Donna was written to provide a “caustic” and “grown-up” attitude towards the Doctor, in opposition to Rose and Martha, who fell in love with him. Tate considered Donna to be more equal to the Doctor because her character did not romanticise him, allowing her to question his morality more easily.

Donna’s mime

In this production, the script requires Catherine Tate, as Donna Noble, to reintroduce herself to The Doctor in mime. The stage directions by writer Russell T Davies are as follows.

Donna does a little mime. I came here, trouble, read about it, internet, I thought, trouble = you! And this place is weird! Pills! So I hid. Back there. Crept along. Looked. You. Cos they…

Tate says Davies had suggested that she might come up with something on the day. She improvised her mime during filming.

Filming

The episode was in the fourth production block in the season, and was filmed in October 2007. The out-of-sequence filming allowed producers to use props to “seed” later episodes; ATMOS, a plot device in the episodes “The Sontaran Stratagem” and “The Poison Sky”, is referred to by a sticker on a taxi’s windscreen. As the episode mostly takes place at night, many scenes were filmed in the early morning.

The scene where Donna and the Doctor investigate Adipose was difficult to film. The scene took thirty shots to complete, and Tennant and Tate experienced problems avoiding each other on-screen. The scene was filmed in a loan company’s call centre in Cardiff’s outskirts on an early Sunday morning, with the company’s telephonists serving as extras.

Exterior shots of Adipose Industries were filmed at the Welsh Gas Board building in Cardiff’s city centre. For health and safety reasons, Tennant was prohibited from performing his own stunts in the window cleaning platform. His only shot that required stunts was when he catches Miss Foster’s sonic pen, a shot that took several takes to perfect.

Adipose

The Adipose were inspired by a stuffed toy Davies owned. The name comes from the scientific name for body fat, adipose tissue. Davies’ brief outlined a “cute” child-friendly creature shaped like a block of lard, similar to the Pillsbury Doughboy. Further consultation with post-production team The Mill resulted in the ears and the singular fang each Adipose has.Stephen Regelous, who won an Academy Award for his software Massive, flew to London to supervise the creation of the crowd special effects. Regelous, a Doctor Who fan, was enthusiastic about helping The Mill with special effects, stating that “When I first found out that the Mill was working on Doctor Who, I was quietly hoping that Massive might be used to create hordes of Daleks or Cybermen and with series 4, I jumped at the opportunity to be involved.” The Mill created two types of Adipose: extras with artificial intelligence and independent movement, and “hero” Adipose, which were hand-animated.

Broadcast and reception

Broadcast and ratings

The episode was broadcast on 5 April 2008 at 18:20, the earliest timeslot since the show’s revival in 2005. Davies criticised the BBC’s scheduling department and claimed the show could lose 1.5 million viewers. The show retained a similar time of broadcast for a further four episodes, before returning to around 19:00. from “The Doctor’s Daughter” onwards.

The preview version of the episode supplied to the press and aired at the press launch omitted the scene that features Rose; before broadcast, only the production team, Tate, and Tennant had seen the scene. The scene contains Rose’s departure theme, “Doomsday”. Tennant commented “on the night of transmission … the Radio Times won’t have told you it’s coming, it’ll come as a genuine [...] prickle up the spine”.

Overnight figures estimated the show was watched by 8.4 million viewers, with a peak of 8.7 million, 39.4% of the television audience. The consolidated rating was 9.1 million viewers. Doctor Who was therefore the most watched show on 5 April, although the Grand National had a higher peak with 10.1 million viewers. The episode’s Appreciation Index was 88 (considered “Excellent”), the highest for any television show aired on 5 April.

Critical reception

The episode received many positive reviews. John Preston, writing for The Daily Telegraph, called the episode an “undiluted triumph”. Opening his review, he said “last night’s episode struck me as being as close to 50 minutes of pure pleasure as you’re likely to get on television”. He noted the episode’s clever tackling of the topical theme of obesity, and its mixture of emotion and special effects. In closing, he said “the dejected critic, denied even the smallest nit to pick, walks glumly away”. Scott Matthewman of The Stage lamented that the Adipose were not threatening enough. He liked the Adipose’s execution of Miss Foster, a “momentary pause in mid-air, gravity only kicking in when the character looks down”, comparing it to Wile E. Coyote and Chuck Jones, which “[was] a nice little touch in an episode … full of them”. He also appreciated Tate, saying that “David Tennant finally has a partner who is approaching an equal”. Sam Wollaston of The Guardian wrote that Tate was “not right for this role” and “too hysterical, too comedy, not cool enough”, and felt her inclusion was an attempt to trade on the popularity of her own series and “broaden the appeal of [Dr Who] still further”. He also found the music “a bit oppressive” but concluded that, despite these criticisms, the show was “still awfully nice television”. Keith Watson of Metro gave the episode 4 stars out of 5. He admitted that despite his dislike of Tate, “she isn’t that bad”. His review of the Adipose was positive, citing them as a reason of the quality of the show. Closing, he said “it split [his] sides”.

Jon Wise of The People said “Doctor Who is a super-galactic way of spending a Saturday night indoors”, and appreciated that Donna was not romantically interested in the Doctor, unlike Martha or Rose. Ben Rawson-Jones gave the episode a wholly positive review, summarising it as containing “pure fantastic family fun, delivering a winning blend of action, comedy, poignancy and one unexpected shock cameo”.

The episode received several negative reviews. Andrew Billen, writing for The Times, lamented that Davies had “forgotten that Doctor Who’s main task is to send children scuttling behind sofas while entertaining their fathers with the odd philosophical idea, the occasional classical reference, a joke or two they would probably not wish to explain and a wee bit of space totty”. Billen also criticised the writing and acting, but commended Tate for a “toned down performance”. Alan Stanley Blair of SyFy Portal summarised it as “a runaway Saturday morning cartoon in desperate need to a solid story”. Blair found flaws with the comedy and the music in the episode, but was impressed with Tate’s acting and Piper’s cameo. Kevin O’Sullivan of the Sunday Mirror criticised Tate and Tennant for overacting, and had concerns about the writing: “It didn’t exactly ooze tension. All we got in the way of terrifying space enemies was Sarah Lancashire hamming it up as an intergalactic super nanny, a couple of security guards with guns and lots of cute little fat babies.”Ian Hyland of News of the World criticised the child-friendly storyline, comparing it to “the back of a fag packet”. He also criticised Tennant for appearing “jaded” and Tate for “still shouting”.